Discussion forum for Eli Manning's fans
(New York Giants, NFL).
Please post trade rumors, injury reports and amateur scout suggestions.
Please do not post inappropriate comments, this is a friendly forum for fans.
If you see inappropriate comments, then please report them by clicking the report abuse link aside the comment.
Comments you post may require a paid membership to delete.
I will take this to my grave. Eli Manning won two Super Bowls strictly on the back of a GREAT supporting cast. If you put Tony Romo in at QB of the 2000s Giants teams they'd probably have 5 Super Bowls. Romo has done more than Eli with less around him.
Hate to admit it, but you can't blame Gomer for this one. If the tattoos make you a better receiver, then why do you keep dropping passes? Manning did his job. the receivers, O-line and secondary lost this one.
I sometimes hear debates on Sports shows about whether ELI deserves the Hall of Fame. Are you kidding me ? He should not even be in the league period. He has been given every opportunity and shown he is not a QB> If he gets into the HOF they need to burn that place down cause it is a joke. He is a JOKE.
I have always felt like if his dad and brother were not nfl quarterbacks that he would not even have been drafted. HE SUCKS its that simple. He has no business in the league and never ever has. He justr became a QB cause his family was.
Thanks for agreeing. Some QBS carry their team; others are carried BY their team. Eli is just lucky. Had he signed with the Chargers, he'd be nobody special and Rivers would have 2 rings (and Rivers is a better QB by far!)