Discussion forum for Eli Manning's fans
(New York Giants, NFL).
Please post trade rumors, injury reports and amateur scout suggestions.
Please do not post inappropriate comments, this is a friendly forum for fans.
If you see inappropriate comments, then please report them by clicking the report abuse link aside the comment.
Comments you post may require a paid membership to delete.
After throwing your best wr you ever had under the bus after having 2 bad game sin a row..Way to proud and to big of an EGO for Eli now he thinks he's the man but has he ever been a consistent qb during the regular season? No he has had some pretty decent ones but overall he is a slightly above avg reg season qb who is no scared to get hit? All of a sudden he is like a rookie again and has happy feet for 3 games in a row now. Throwing picks and fumbling at am alarming rate. I lost all respect for Eli and Ben Macadoo for public criticism of their best most passionate player. Tom Coughlin should still be here I wanted him gone but they needed to get rid of his staff and keep him. Eli now is put in a position wherequires nooNE on the team knew Eli when he was a joke getting run out of the NFL before he went crazy on 07 and then in 2011. Now he has this ego and no one tp reign him in. Like the dynamic has shifted from Tom and Elis team to just Elis and he can't had handle that. He can't handle emotional players and is not a vocal leader..all things that with a great coach great defense and the right timing aren't as big of a deal as when he is 36 almost and should be the leader of this team in every way. No Strahan or Tuck or Osi or Jacobs just Eli and he is proving very quickly he isn't quite made of the stuff we thought. He is a baby and has no fire..Always lauded for his ability to stay calm which comes in handy in the playoffs but has led to him being one of the most inconsistent 2 time sb winning qbs ever.Actually it's not even close he by far the most inconsistent ever. He makes so many bad tgrows is disturbing even last year he made a few huge mistakes that for a vet qb you just don't see that happen. Yeah even qb has a bad game or maybe even 2 but I don't see any Vets that Eli is supposed to be on their level ever make some of the ridiculous bad timed ill placed throws that Eli makes almost weekly. Ben is garbage the defense is OK keep spags if you want but still.could probably do better in that area as well. Macadoo has this offense running like they have an OLINE or a good RB esp with no Jennings don't come out and do what you did in the second half late and mix it up..throw a screen to Beckham at least 2 or 3 a.game and Shepard to should get 3 or 4 high percentage targets early period idk what the defense is doing.
Time for the Giants too start looking for Eli's successor he is slow and fumble prone and not very accurate, it is just time to move on. Also new GM someone who will draft a good LB and some lineman and a good all around TE.